A Carnival cruise guest has filed suit alleging she was injured when a bench collapsed during a popular Bahamas excursion to “Pig Beach,” a shore excursion where visitors swim with semi-wild pigs. The case is a useful illustration of a question that comes up constantly in cruise injury law: when passengers are hurt on an excursion the cruise line sold them but didn’t necessarily operate directly, who actually bears the legal responsibility?
What the Lawsuit Alleges
According to the suit, the passenger was injured when a bench gave way during the shore excursion, which was booked through Carnival. The case raises questions about the condition of the equipment and seating provided at the excursion site, and whether Carnival exercised reasonable care in selecting, vetting, or overseeing the company that operated the excursion.
Cruise Lines and Third-Party Shore Excursions
Most shore excursions, including popular ones like swimming with pigs in the Bahamas, snorkeling trips, or zipline tours, are operated by local, independent companies rather than the cruise line itself. Cruise lines typically market and sell tickets for these excursions as part of the cruise experience, which creates an important legal question: does selling and promoting the excursion create a duty of care toward passengers, even if the cruise line isn’t running the activity itself?
Courts have generally held that cruise lines can be liable for injuries on a third-party excursion if the cruise line failed to use reasonable care in selecting a safe and competent excursion operator, or if it held the excursion out as its own in a way that created an expectation of the cruise line’s own safety standards.
What Plaintiffs Typically Need to Show
In a shore excursion injury case like this one, a plaintiff generally needs to show that the cruise line was negligent in vetting or selecting the operator — for example, ignoring a history of safety complaints, prior injuries, or inadequate equipment at the excursion site. This often requires discovery into the cruise line’s vetting process and any prior incident reports involving the same excursion or operator.
Maritime Law and Strict Deadlines Still Apply
As with other claims against cruise lines, shore excursion injury cases are typically governed by federal maritime law and the passenger ticket’s terms, which commonly require written notice within six months of the injury and a lawsuit filed within one year. These deadlines apply whether the injury happened on the ship itself or during a land-based excursion sold through the cruise line.
What to Do If You’re Injured on a Shore Excursion
- Report the injury to both the excursion operator and the ship’s medical staff as soon as possible.
- Take photos of the equipment, seating, or condition that caused the injury.
- Keep your excursion ticket, confirmation, and any marketing materials showing it was sold through the cruise line.
- Identify witnesses, including other passengers on the same excursion.
- Speak with a maritime injury attorney promptly given the short filing deadlines involved.
Shore excursions are often presented as a seamless part of the cruise experience, but the legal relationship between the cruise line and the operator running the activity is rarely seamless. Understanding that relationship is often the key to determining who’s actually responsible when something goes wrong.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. If you’ve been injured on a cruise or shore excursion, consult a licensed attorney experienced in maritime law promptly.